Fuel is one of the largest ongoing expenses of vehicle ownership. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the average American household spends over $3,000 per year on gasoline. When shopping for a new car, comparing the fuel costs of your current vehicle against potential replacements is one of the most practical steps you can take to understand the true cost difference.
Our fuel savings calculator above makes this comparison simple: enter the fuel economy for two vehicles, your annual driving distance, and the price of gas, and instantly see how much you could save per year, per month, and over five years. Whether you are comparing a truck against a sedan, evaluating a hybrid, or deciding between two similar models, this tool gives you the numbers you need.
What Is a Fuel Savings Calculator?
A fuel savings calculator compares the annual fuel cost of two vehicles to determine the difference—your potential savings. Unlike a simple fuel cost calculator that estimates the cost of a single trip, a fuel savings calculator projects costs over time (annually, monthly, and multi-year) to help with purchase decisions.
This is valuable in several scenarios:
- Buying a new car. See how much you would save in fuel by choosing a more efficient model. A $900/year fuel savings over 5 years equals $4,500—which can offset a higher purchase price.
- Keeping vs. replacing. If your current vehicle costs $3,000/year in fuel and a newer model would cost $1,500, the $1,500 annual savings helps justify the upgrade.
- Comparing two options. When deciding between a 25 MPG crossover and a 32 MPG sedan, the calculator shows the exact dollar difference at your driving habits.
- Evaluating a commute vehicle. Long-distance commuters benefit most from fuel-efficient vehicles. Use this alongside our Commute Gas Cost Calculator for a complete picture.
How to Calculate Fuel Savings Between Two Vehicles
The fuel savings formula computes the annual fuel cost for each vehicle and finds the difference:
For metric users (L/100km):
You can project savings over any time period by multiplying the annual savings:
Worked Examples With Real Numbers
Example 1: SUV vs. Sedan
You currently drive an SUV getting 20 MPG and are considering a sedan that gets 35 MPG. You drive 12,000 miles per year and gas costs $3.50/gallon.
Annual savings: $900 | Monthly: $75 | 5-year: $4,500
Example 2: Old Car vs. New Model
Your 2010 vehicle gets 22 MPG. The 2025 model of the same car gets 32 MPG. You drive 15,000 miles/year at $3.60/gallon.
Annual savings: $767 | Monthly: $64 | 5-year: $3,836
Example 3: Compact vs. Hybrid
Comparing a 30 MPG compact car against a 50 MPG hybrid. 10,000 miles/year at $3.40/gallon.
Annual savings: $453 | Monthly: $38 | 5-year: $2,267
When Does Upgrading Your Vehicle Make Financial Sense?
Upgrading to a more fuel-efficient vehicle is not always the right financial decision. The key question is whether the fuel savings justify the cost of the new vehicle (minus trade-in value of the old one). Here is a simple framework:
- Calculate your annual fuel savings using the calculator above.
- Determine the net cost of the upgrade: new vehicle price minus trade-in value of your current vehicle.
- Divide the net cost by annual fuel savings to find the payback period in years.
Factors That Affect Real-World Fuel Savings
Driving Habits and Conditions
EPA fuel economy ratings are tested under controlled conditions. Real-world MPG varies based on driving style, terrain, and traffic. Aggressive driving can reduce fuel economy by 15–30%, while smooth highway driving may exceed EPA estimates. The U.S. Department of Energy recommends using your actual tracked MPG (via our Gas Mileage Calculator) rather than EPA ratings for the most accurate savings comparison.
Gas Price Fluctuations
Fuel savings scale directly with gas prices. When gas is $3.00/gallon, the savings difference between a 20 MPG and 35 MPG vehicle is $771/year. At $4.50/gallon, that same difference grows to $1,157/year. Higher gas prices make fuel-efficient vehicles even more valuable.
Annual Mileage
The more you drive, the more you save with a fuel-efficient vehicle. A driver covering 20,000 miles/year saves 67% more than someone driving 12,000 miles/year with the same MPG difference. High-mileage drivers—especially commuters—benefit most from fuel-efficient upgrades.
City vs. Highway Driving Mix
Some vehicles are significantly more efficient on the highway than in the city (and vice versa for hybrids). When comparing vehicles, consider your typical driving mix and use the appropriate EPA rating (city, highway, or combined).
Annual Fuel Cost Comparison by Vehicle Type
The following table compares estimated annual fuel costs for common vehicle categories, assuming 12,000 miles/year and $3.50/gallon:
| Vehicle Type | Typical MPG | Annual Fuel Cost | Savings vs. 20 MPG |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full-size truck | 17 MPG | $2,471 | −$371 (costs more) |
| Large SUV | 20 MPG | $2,100 | $0 (baseline) |
| Midsize SUV | 26 MPG | $1,615 | $485/year |
| Midsize sedan | 32 MPG | $1,313 | $788/year |
| Compact car | 36 MPG | $1,167 | $933/year |
| Hybrid sedan | 50 MPG | $840 | $1,260/year |
| Plug-in hybrid | 60+ MPGe | $700 | $1,400/year |
As the table shows, moving from a 20 MPG SUV to a 50 MPG hybrid saves over $1,200 per year—or more than $6,000 over five years. For an even more detailed comparison including electric vehicles, see our Gas vs Electric Car Cost Calculator.
Beyond Fuel: Total Cost of Ownership
While fuel savings are important, they are only one component of total vehicle ownership cost. When comparing vehicles, also consider:
- Insurance premiums. Larger vehicles and newer models may have higher insurance costs. Get quotes for both vehicles before deciding.
- Maintenance costs. Newer vehicles typically have lower maintenance costs. Hybrids may need less brake work due to regenerative braking. However, hybrid battery replacement (if needed) can cost $2,000–$5,000.
- Depreciation. This is the largest cost of vehicle ownership for new cars. A new car loses 20–30% of its value in the first year. Buying a 2–3 year old used vehicle avoids the steepest depreciation while still offering good fuel economy.
- Financing costs. A more expensive fuel-efficient vehicle may require higher monthly payments. Calculate whether the fuel savings offset the additional financing cost.
- Tax credits and incentives. Some fuel-efficient vehicles, hybrids, and EVs qualify for federal and state tax credits that can reduce the effective purchase price by $2,500–$7,500.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much can I save by switching to a more fuel-efficient car?
Savings depend on the MPG difference, your annual mileage, and gas prices. As a general example, going from 20 MPG to 35 MPG at 12,000 miles/year and $3.50/gallon saves $900 per year or $4,500 over 5 years. The bigger the MPG gap and the more you drive, the greater the savings.
Should I use EPA MPG or real-world MPG in the calculator?
Use real-world MPG whenever possible for the most accurate comparison. Track your current vehicle's MPG over several fill-ups using our Gas Mileage Calculator. For a vehicle you have not driven yet, the EPA combined rating is a reasonable starting point, but expect real-world results to be 10–20% lower.
Is a hybrid worth the extra cost?
It depends on the price premium and your driving habits. A hybrid typically costs $2,000–$5,000 more than the gas equivalent. If the hybrid saves $800–$1,200/year in fuel, the payback period is 2–6 years. High-mileage drivers and those with long commutes benefit most. Use our calculator to see your specific numbers.
How does gas price affect my fuel savings?
Fuel savings scale proportionally with gas prices. If your savings are $900/year at $3.50/gallon, they would be approximately $1,157/year at $4.50/gallon and $643/year at $2.50/gallon. Higher gas prices make fuel-efficient vehicles an even better investment.
Does the improvement from 15 to 20 MPG save as much as from 30 to 35 MPG?
No. Due to the math of division, improvements at the low end of the MPG scale save significantly more fuel. Going from 15 to 20 MPG at 12,000 miles saves 200 gallons/year ($700). Going from 30 to 35 MPG saves only 57 gallons/year ($200). This is why upgrading the least efficient vehicle in your household often yields the biggest savings.
Can I compare a gas vehicle to an electric vehicle with this calculator?
This calculator is designed for comparing two gas-powered vehicles by MPG. For gas vs. electric vehicle comparisons that factor in electricity rates and kWh per mile, use our specialized Gas vs Electric Car Cost Calculator.
Know Your Current Vehicle's MPG?
Track your real-world fuel economy for a more accurate savings comparison.
Calculate Your MPG